Ad copy

I used to fake my 'amens' in Bible study just to seem like I still had it together. Till I couldn't anymore. The woman next to me had just shared something raw, her son, his diagnosis, how she'd been begging God for an answer for months. Everyone murmured "mmm" and "yes, Lord" and I did too, right on cue. But I felt nothing. Not nothing like peace. Nothing like a dead phone screen. Black. No signal. I'd been going to that Tuesday night group for six years. I knew when to nod. I knew the rhythm of the room. My mouth still knew the words to the songs. But somewhere in the last year, my chest had stopped saying them with me. I told myself it was a season. Everybody has seasons. Then it was two seasons. Then I stopped counting. I want to tell you what actually happened, because I think you already know part of this story. I think you're already nodding, and I don't mean that in a cute copywriter way. I mean I think your jaw just tightened a little. Here's the part nobody says out loud in church: I wasn't angry at God. I want to be really clear about that, because I spent a long time assuming anger was the only respectable reason to feel this far away. Anger has a plot. Anger has a villain. What I had was quieter and much harder to explain at a potluck. I'd pray and hear my own voice bounce off the ceiling. I'd open my Bible app in the church parking lot, sit there for four minutes, and close it without reading a verse. Just sat with my hands on the wheel. I told my husband I was "just tired." I told my small group leader I was "in a dry season, praying through it." Both true. Neither the real thing. The real thing was this, I didn't feel far from God because I doubted Him. I felt far from Him because I couldn't feel anything, about anything, most days. Not just Him. My own daughter's laugh barely landed. My best friend's wedding, I cried at the right moment because I knew that was the moment to cry, not because it moved through me. If you've never had that happen, this might sound strange. If you have, I think your stomach just dropped a little, reading this. I started wondering if this was just what getting older in your faith looked like. Some quiet, permanent fog that nobody warns the new believers about. I asked my mother once, carefully, if she'd ever felt this. She said, "Just pray more, honey. He's not the one who moved." I nodded. I went home and prayed for eleven minutes with a timer running in my head the whole time, and afterward felt exactly the same amount of nothing I'd felt before I started. I want to be honest about what I tried, because I think you've tried it too and I don't want you to feel stupid for it not working. It wasn't stupid. It just wasn't aimed at the actual thing. I did a 21-day prayer challenge from a book my sister gave me. I made it to day nine and quietly let it go, the way you let go of a diet nobody's checking on. I listened to worship music in the car on the way to work, some mornings crying, most mornings just driving. I signed up for a women's retreat two hours away, paid the deposit, felt something crack open for about six hours on a Saturday, and by the following Wednesday was back to reciting my "amens" on autopilot like nothing had happened at all. Here's the part I actually want to tell you about, because it's the part that changed things, and it happened in a way I never would have guessed. My friend Renata texted me at almost midnight. Not a normal time for her, she's the one who's usually asleep by nine because of her boys' school schedule. The text just said, "Are you up? I need to tell you something and I don't want to say it in daylight for some reason." She told me she'd been using something for about six weeks and hadn't told a single person, not even her husband. She said it felt too fragile to explain yet, like if she said it out loud too early it might stop being true. It was a journal. Called Back to You. Made by a company called Held & Honest. I almost didn't ask more. Journals had never worked for me, I have at least four half-used ones in a drawer, guilt objects more than tools. But something about the way she said it, like she was confessing, not recommending, made me ask what was different. She said the first prompt didn't ask her anything about God at all. It asked what her body needed right now that it wasn't getting. She said she sat there annoyed for a second, like, I paid for a Christian journal and it's asking me about sleep and water. But she answered it anyway. And she said something in her chest went quiet in a way it hadn't in years. Not "healed." Quiet. Like a room where someone finally turned off a fan that had been running so long she'd forgotten it was on. I ordered mine three days later. I didn't tell anyone either, honestly, for close to a month. I want to tell you what I understood, slowly, not all at once, because it didn't arrive as a lesson, it arrived as a feeling first, and I only had words for it later. I wasn't spiritually dead. I wasn't backslidden. I wasn't even really in a "dry season" in the way my mother meant it. I was frozen. Not frozen like stuck. Frozen like your hand under cold water for too long, the kind of frozen where the nerve endings themselves stop transmitting, not because the feeling isn't there, but because the whole system decided, a long time ago, under some pressure I probably couldn't even name, that it was safer to stop feeling so much. Safer to go quiet. Safer to nod along at Bible study than to feel the full size of anything in a room full of people. Nobody at church could see that, because it doesn't look like doubt. It looks like a woman who shows up every week and knows all the words. The journal never told me any of this directly, by the way. I want to be honest about that too. It didn't diagnose me. It just kept asking these small, oddly gentle questions that didn't rush me anywhere. Some entries in the first couple weeks I wrote four words and closed it. One night, I don't even know how far in I was, I noticed I'd written almost a full page about my dad's funeral without meaning to, and I hadn't cried once while writing it, and afterward I sat on my closet floor and cried for twenty minutes about something completely unrelated, and it didn't feel like falling apart. It felt like a window finally opening in a room that had been sealed shut. I'm not going to pretend it was a straight line. There was a stretch, maybe three weeks in, where I skipped four days in a row and felt that old guilt creeping back, the "you're failing at this too" voice. I almost put it in the drawer with the others. I didn't, mostly out of stubbornness. I'm glad, but I want you to know it wasn't tidy. What I can tell you is this. A few months in, my daughter said something funny at dinner, one of those dumb little-kid non-sequiturs, and I laughed before I decided to laugh. Not the performed laugh. The other kind. My husband looked up like he'd noticed something without knowing what. And at Bible study, the same Tuesday group, the same folding chairs, somebody shared something hard a few weeks ago, and I felt my own chest tighten before I even opened my mouth. I said "yes, Lord" and I meant it enough that it startled me a little, saying it. I keep thinking about how close I came to just accepting the fog as permanent. How many more years I might have spent showing up, saying the words, teaching my daughter the songs, while quietly believing some part of me was gone for good. It wasn't gone. It was frozen. Those aren't the same thing, and I wish somebody had told me that difference years earlier instead of "just pray more." I'm not writing this to sell you anything, and if it reads that way I'm sorry, that's not what this is. I just think a woman is reading this right now who fakes her amens too. Who knows all the words and feels none of the room. Who thinks the problem is her faith, when the truth might just be that no one ever told her frozen and gone are different things, and that one of them thaws.