Ashley Carter Facebook ad: “I Read One-Star Reviews First”

Running for 36 days since October 16, 2026. Crush last saw it on November 21, 2026.
Run by Ashley Carter on Facebook. Crush is not the advertiser and does not verify its claims. See this ad in Meta's Ad Library(opens in a new tab)
Make your own version of this ad
Crush makes it, launches it in your own Meta ad account, scales the winners and pauses the losers.
About this ad
- Meta Ad Library ID
- 854674171037564
- Platforms
- Facebook, Instagram, Audience Network, WhatsApp and Threads
- Relaunches
- 0
- Niche
- Hair Care
Ad text
The box was so flat I checked the order twice, because I was fairly sure they had sent me a placemat. Checking things twice is what the university pays me to do — I coordinate a graduate program, which is forty hours a week of finding mistakes in other people's forms. I'm also not a fun person to shop online with. I read the one-star reviews first. I have a standing rule about cute things on the internet: if it looks that good in the photos, there is something they're not showing you. Which is why I nearly talked myself out of this one. I'd seen one at a coffee place on State Street here in Madison — the woman ahead of me set it on the counter while she paid, and I spent my whole wait in line trying to work out what it even was. I found it online that night. Then I let it sit in my cart for four days like it owed me an explanation. I finally ordered on the last Sunday night in September. The confirmation came, the shipping email came, and then, the first week of October, a mailer showed up on our porch that was thinner than most of the paperwork on my desk. I opened it standing at our kitchen counter. Inside were two flat, folded, woven things pressed as flat as dish towels, and a little bundle of braided rope. They had stripes. They were the exact size and shape of the placemats at my mother's house in Eau Claire. My roommate Priya walked in, looked at the counter, and said, "Did you order placemats?" "No," I said, with the full confidence of a woman who had, apparently, ordered placemats. I set one flat on the counter. Priya put her coffee mug on it. It looked right at home. I took a photo and sent it to my group chat — six girls I've known since undergrad — with the caption "they sent me placemats." Three of them replied with some version of "they look nice though." So I did the thing I do for a living, which is pull up the order and read it line by line, twice. It said Bucky — the Pop-Up Bucket Bag. "Pop-up" felt ambitious for something Priya was actively using as a coaster. But fine. I unfolded the first one, found the magnetic snap at the top, and gave it a skeptical little shake. And the thing popped open into a bucket. An actual round little bag, standing upright on my kitchen counter, with four metal rings set in eyelets along the top edge. I said "oh" out loud. Priya had her phone up and filming before I touched the rope. The braided rope handles clip onto the metal rings — two per bag, and they come off and swap between the bags. I clipped mine on slowly, like a ceremony, while Priya narrated in a nature-documentary voice. The thing she had been using as a coaster was now a little woven bucket bag, sitting upright on our counter as if it had never been anything else. She sent the video to the group chat with the caption "jenna's placemat: part two." It got more replies than my birthday did. It carries what I actually use in a day and not one thing more. Small on purpose, and I knew that going in. It is one open compartment — no lining, no pockets, nowhere to hide a system. If your bag needs pockets inside pockets, this is not that bag. Everything I own sits in one small open room, and I can see all of it the second the snap opens. It has come to the office with me every day for two weeks. It sits on my desk being the nicest-looking thing in the room, which is not a high bar in a university administrative office, but still. On Saturday a woman at brunch asked where it was from while we were still waiting on our table. I showed her the video instead of answering, because the video is better than any answer. And here's the part Priya would want me to include. There was a two for one, so there were two placemats, which became two bags, and the handles swap between them — Priya has the pink handles on the striped one now. If you've ever ordered something cute online and braced yourself for the version that shows up looking nothing like the photos. If you're the one in your group chat who gets sent every "should I get this?" link, because you're the one who actually checks. If you've been hauling a big bag to brunch and the grocery store when everything you actually needed was your phone, your keys, and a lip balm. The handles have swapped twice since, and neither of us plans to stop. emmafy.com/products/bucky-the-pop-up-bucket-bag
Where the ad sends people
emmafy.com
I Read One-Star Reviews First
Then it popped open
Shop now: emmafy.com(opens in a new tab)










