Ad copy

My guests left three cigarette burns on the granite countertop. In a row. Like someone had stubbed them out one after another while standing at the counter, deliberately, not the way you'd burn a counter by accident. Three black-edged divots in a perfect line on the kitchen island I'd had refinished four months earlier for $1,400 because the previous tenants had let their kid color on it with permanent marker. The cigarette burns weren't the worst of it. The white sectional in the living room had a stain on it the size of a dinner plate. I couldn't tell what color it was. Some kind of brown-purple. I couldn't tell what it was either, which was somehow worse than knowing. There were three broken plates stacked neatly in the sink like they thought I wouldn't notice if they organized the evidence. The lampshade in the bedroom was on sideways — not knocked off, sideways, like somebody had been wearing it. There was a smear on the front door deadbolt the color of dried lipstick that I didn't want to investigate. I sat down on the floor of the living room, in the corner where the sectional doesn't reach, and I cried for about twenty minutes. The kind of crying where you don't make any noise because you're 39 years old and you live alone and there's nobody to hear you anyway. I'm a single mom. I have one daughter, Emma, she's 8. I'm an Airbnb host. The condo I was sitting in the middle of is my entire income. I got it in the divorce two years ago and instead of selling it I rented it out, because the mortgage was already paid down to $980 a month and I figured if I could keep it booked I could pay the mortgage and clear maybe another $2,200 in a good month, which is more than I was making at the dental office I quit to take care of Emma after the divorce. I had three weeks of bookings cancelled the moment I called my cleaner Rosa and told her not to come because the place wasn't going to be ready by check-in. The damage was going to cost me, at the very best estimate, $3,800 to fix. The deposit was $500. Airbnb's "AirCover" was going to fight me on every line item. I had $812 in my checking account. The mortgage was due in nine days. I sat on the floor in the corner and did the math three different ways and it kept coming out the same: I was going to miss the mortgage payment for the first time since the divorce. But that's not what this story is about. This story is about what happened when I opened the Airbnb app to file the damage claim. There's a thing every host knows. When guests trash your place, they leave you a one-star review first. They do it preemptively, before you can review them. They write something about how the apartment was dirty or the host was rude or the wifi didn't work, and they leave it as a one-star so that when you write up your damage claim you look like a vindictive host going after a guest who already complained. It's a known move. Every host group on Facebook has a thread about it every week. So I knew, sitting on the floor of my wrecked condo, that I wasn't just looking at $3,800 in damage and a missed mortgage. I was looking at a one-star review that would tank my next two months of bookings, because a 4.9 rating with one one-star review at the top is the kiss of death for a new listing month. I opened the app expecting the one-star. Five stars. I read it three times. I thought it was a glitch. I refreshed. Still five stars. I scrolled down to read the review and I was looking for the catch — the "but" — the line that would be the setup for the chargeback complaint. There was no "but." The review barely mentioned the apartment. It mentioned the location for one line. It mentioned the kitchen for half a line. The whole rest of the review — and it was a long review, four paragraphs, longer than most five-star reviews I've ever gotten — was about the bed. "Slept better than I have in years. I don't know what kind of mattress this is but I'm going to figure it out and buy one. My boyfriend usually snores and he didn't snore once. I forgot what it was like to wake up without my back hurting. I would book this place again just to sleep in this bed." I sat there with the phone in my hand looking at the cigarette burns and the stain and the broken plates and I could not understand what I was reading. These people had destroyed my apartment. They had clearly done something in there that I was never going to be able to fully picture. And the only thing they wanted to talk about in their review was the bed. I never found out what they did in that apartment. I gave up trying to guess. Whatever it was, they slept like babies afterward. Rosa showed up the next morning to help me start the cleanup. Rosa has been my cleaner for two years. She also cleans five other short-term rentals in the same neighborhood — a guy with three units near the convention center, a couple who do the duplex over on 4th Street, an older woman who has a casita behind her main house. Rosa has been cleaning short-term rentals for eight years. She has seen everything. When she walked into my condo and saw the damage she just nodded, set down her bucket, and said "I've seen worse, mija. We'll fix it." I made coffee in the half-functional kitchen and we sat at the dining table with the broken plates in the sink behind us and I told her about the review. I showed her the phone. She read it. She handed the phone back. "That's the topper, honey." "What topper?" She looked at me. "The one I put on the bed four months ago. You don't remember?" I didn't remember. I'd been so deep in the cancellation aftermath after that bad month — the month I'd gotten three reviews in a row complaining the bed was too firm, then two saying the bed was too soft, then the one that said "tossed and turned all night" that dropped my rating from 4.9 to 4.7 — that I'd told Rosa to "try anything" and then mentally checked out because Emma had strep that week and I was running on no sleep. "You told me to try anything," Rosa said. "You said you'd pay for whatever I needed. I flipped the mattress first. When I flipped it I saw the topper you had on there — the one from Amazon — was flat as a pancake. Compressed in the middle. Like a hammock. I threw it out." "Rosa. That topper was $79." "It was killing your reviews, mija. The guests were sleeping in a hole. Their hips were sinking, their shoulders were sinking, their backs were arched all night. Of course they were tossing. I cleaned a unit on 4th Street for two years with the same problem and the owner finally bought a different kind — a Hanare. Three inches, bamboo cover. She said her reviews went from 4.6 to 4.9 in three months. So I bought one for your place too. I figured I'd tell you when the bookings stabilized. Then Emma had strep and you stopped answering texts about anything that wasn't her. I never told you." "Rosa. You spent your own money on a topper for my apartment?" "$139. I was going to put it on your invoice. Then I forgot. Then your reviews fixed themselves and I figured you'd notice eventually." I had not noticed. I went back into the app while Rosa started bagging up the kitchen and I looked at my last twelve reviews. Nine of them mentioned the bed. I hadn't seen it because I'd been looking for problems and the bed had stopped being a problem four months ago. The "tossed all night" reviews stopped on March 14th. Rosa had texted me about the topper on March 12th and I'd written back "yes do whatever just fix it please" and then I'd forgotten the entire conversation because Emma was running 103 and I had a guest checking in the next morning and the dishwasher was leaking. The five-star review from the apartment-trashers was the loudest version of a thing that had been happening quietly for four months. I went home that night — well, I went to my mom's house, because I'd been staying with my mom on the nights I was cleaning between guests since the divorce, which was most nights — and I sat at her kitchen table and I looked up what Rosa had put on my bed. The first thing I found wasn't a sales page. It was a write-up about a study published in The Lancet — a real medical journal, the kind doctors actually read — where researchers in Spain took 313 patients with chronic lower back pain and randomly assigned them to sleep on different mattress firmnesses for 90 days. The group on medium-firm surfaces had significantly less pain than the group on soft, sink-in surfaces. The soft surfaces — pillowtops, memory foam, the conforming kind that "feels comfortable" in the showroom — performed the worst. The article explained why. Your spine has a natural curve in the lower back. A medium-firm surface supports that curve from underneath. A sink-in surface fills in around the curve and flattens it. After eight hours of being held flat, your discs don't decompress. Your back muscles don't release. You micro-wake all night without remembering and wake up feeling like you didn't sleep, because you didn't, not really. That's exactly what the Amazon topper had been doing to my guests. The topper had been firm for the first month or so. By month three it had collapsed into a hammock and every guest who slept on it spent eight hours with their spine bent like a banana. They woke up sore, they wrote "tossed all night" in the review, and my rating slipped from 4.9 to 4.7 to 4.5. I had thought it was the mattress. The mattress was fine. The mattress was a $1,200 Beautyrest that was three years old and barely broken in. The topper was the problem. The topper I had bought to *fix* the problem was the problem. There was a second study from Japanese researchers about sleep temperature — your body needs to drop one degree Fahrenheit at the skin surface to enter deep sleep, and polyester covers (which is what 95% of mattresses and almost all Amazon toppers have) trap heat and prevent the drop. My guests had been micro-waking from heat all night on top of being bent backwards by the collapsed topper. No wonder they hated the bed. No wonder Rosa's Hanare — bamboo viscose cover, breathable, medium-firm support layer engineered not to collapse — had fixed it. I sat at my mom's kitchen table at 11 PM and I did a different kind of math. A one-star review costs me, on average, about $900 in lost bookings over the next 60 days — based on my data, the dip in occupancy after the two bad reviews in February. Some hosts say it's more. The cigarette-burn guests, if they'd left me a one-star to cover their tracks, would have cost me $900 in addition to the $3,800 in damage. The topper that prevented that one-star cost $139. I sat there at the kitchen table and I thought about every host in my Facebook group who's been spiraling over a 4.5 rating, trying new pillows, new sheets, new linens, new bath products, scented candles, welcome baskets, anything to get a guest to write a nice review — and none of them are looking at the topper, because the mattress is "fine," because the bed "looks great," because the topper they put on is "from a good brand on Amazon" and it was $79 and how could that be the problem. The topper is always the problem. The mattress is almost never the problem. Hosts are spending $1,800 on new mattresses every two years to fix a problem that's $139 to fix on top of a perfectly good bed. My mom was watching me at the table. She'd been making chamomile tea for both of us and she set the cup down and asked what I was reading. I told her. I told her about the review. I told her about Rosa. I told her about the topper. She got quiet for a minute. Then she said "Honey, my back has been killing me. Could I try one?" My mom is 66. She's been complaining about her back since my dad left in 2009. I've heard about her back for fifteen years. I had never once thought it might be her mattress. She'd had the same Sealy from before the divorce and she always said it was "fine." I ordered one for her bed that night. King size, same as my rental. $139. It came four days later. I drove over and put it on her bed myself while she made us lunch. I didn't tell her how to use it. I just put it on under the sheet and made the bed back up. She called me at 7 AM the next day. "Jessica." "Yeah." "What did you put on my bed." "A mattress topper. The same one Rosa put on the Airbnb." "I slept eight hours. I slept eight hours, Jessica. I haven't slept eight hours since your father left." She was crying. I was crying. Emma was asking what was wrong from the back seat because I'd been driving her to school. Nothing was wrong. Mom was sleeping. She called me a week later and offered to watch Emma on Thursday nights too — she'd been doing Saturday and Sunday since the divorce because that was all she could handle physically. Now she said she had energy. She wanted Thursday. She said "I forgot what it was like to have energy at 6 PM." That was three months ago. My rating is back to 4.9. I've gotten eleven more reviews mentioning the bed specifically. I've stopped checking the reviews obsessively because they're all the same — "the bed was amazing," "best sleep of the trip," "I want to know what mattress this is." I tell them, in my responses. I tell every single one. Half of them DM me afterwards asking where to buy it. Mom has Emma on Thursdays now. I have one weeknight a week I don't have to be a mom. I used it last Thursday to take a bath at 7 PM, which is something I haven't done since the divorce. The cigarette-burn guests cost me $3,800 in damages and AirCover paid me $2,100 of it after a six-week fight. I missed the mortgage payment that month and paid a $47 late fee. I made it up the next month because the five-star review from the cigarette-burn people kept my calendar full when it would have been empty. The $139 topper that Rosa put on my bed without telling me saved me from the one-star that would have cost me the condo. I'm not a doctor. I'm not a sleep scientist. I'm a single mom with one Airbnb who almost lost her mortgage because her guests' Amazon topper went flat. But I've now read the research and the research is clear: most beds in America — including most hotel beds, most Airbnb beds, and most of your own beds — are sleeping people on surfaces that compress the wrong way and trap heat. You're blaming your back. You're blaming your age. You're blaming your stress. You're spending money on chiropractors and pillows and new mattresses. The surface is the problem. The surface is $139 to fix. If you're an Airbnb host and your reviews keep mentioning "the bed" — read this twice. The topper you have on there now is almost certainly the problem, not the mattress. Every one-star review costs you $900. The fix costs $139. Run the math. If you're a VRBO host, a B&B owner, a hotel operator, or anyone who rents a room with a bed in it — same math. The fastest way to a five-star review is a guest who sleeps. Your linens don't matter. Your welcome basket doesn't matter. Your soap doesn't matter. The bed matters. Fix the bed. If you have a guest room your in-laws complain about — get one. Put it on the guest bed. They'll stop complaining. They'll start visiting more, which is either what you want or what you don't, and that's between you and your in-laws. If you've been blaming your own back pain on aging, on stress, on your job, on your weight — read the Lancet study. I'll save you the trip: the surface you sleep on is doing more damage than aging. Aging gets blamed for a lot of things the surface is doing. If you're a single mom or a single dad reading this and the rental is your income and one bad month means a missed mortgage — I see you. I am you. Get the topper before the cigarette-burn guests show up. They will show up. They show up at every Airbnb eventually. Make sure when they do, your bed is so good they forget what they did. Hanare. Three inches. Bamboo cover. Sits on top of any bed. $139. 100-night return. They sell out. Rosa told me she's recommended them to two other hosts she cleans for and one of them had to wait twelve days for restock. If it's in stock tonight, order it tonight. Every booking on a bad surface is a one-star you can't take back. [https://tryhanare.com/products/hanare-mattress-topper](https://tryhanare.com/products/hanare-mattress-topper) P.S. — Rosa charged me $139 for the topper on her next invoice and I paid it without blinking. I also gave her a $400 bonus that month because she had saved my apartment without telling me and she had been right not to ask permission. She told me a cleaner's job is to make the place better than you found it. She'd been doing it for two years and I'd never told her how much she'd done for me. If you have a cleaner, tip her this month. She knows more about your business than you do. P.P.S. — A practical thing. The topper comes in a box smaller than you expect and it's heavier than it looks. Don't try to put it on the bed by yourself if you have a king. It takes two people about ten minutes to unroll and the topper expands on the bed over about 15 minutes. You don't need to change anything else about the bed. Sheets fit over it normally. Guests can't see it from the doorway. It is invisible. They will write a five-star review and they will mention the bed and they will not know what's making the bed feel different. Some of them will try to buy your mattress. They won't know it's the topper. That's part of the magic. P.P.P.S. — The 100-night return is real. I checked it after I bought my mom's one in case she hated it. It's not 30 days, not 60 days. 100 nights. You don't ship it back in the original box (I threw mine out the day it arrived). They send a return label, you put it in a garbage bag, they pick it up, they refund you. No restocking fee. If you've been burned by Amazon toppers like I was — and if you're a host you have, you have a closet full of $79 toppers that went flat in three months — the return policy is your protection. Mine is still going strong after four months. Rosa's friend's at 4th Street is going on two years. P.P.P.P.S. — Rosa told me to add this. She says: if you're a cleaner reading this for one of your hosts, just buy it and put it on the bed. Don't ask. The host will not understand what you're doing because hosts don't think about the topper, they think about the mattress. Put it on, throw out the flat Amazon one, save the receipt. The reviews will fix themselves in three weeks. The host will figure out what you did when she finally looks. Then she will tip you the way I tipped Rosa. Rosa says she has done this for three of her hosts now without asking and not one of them has been mad. Two of them gave her a raise. P.P.P.P.P.S. — I never figured out what those guests did in my apartment. Rosa scrubbed the counter and the burns came out with enough baking soda. The stain on the couch turned out to be wine and red lipstick — Rosa figured that out with a UV light she carries. The broken plates were the cheap ones I'd been meaning to replace anyway. The lampshade went back on straight. The smear on the deadbolt was just lipstick. I never found out if there was a party, an affair, a fight, or just one really chaotic weekend. They left me a five-star review. They never booked again. I hope they're sleeping well wherever they are. They taught me the most expensive lesson of my career and they didn't even know they were teaching it. https://tryhanare.com/products/hanare-mattress-topper